Guide
Fixed-Payment vs Equal-Principal Mortgages: Where the Gap Is Widest
Two mortgages for the same amount, at the same rate, over the same term can cost different amounts in total — because the repayment shape differs. On $300,000 at 5.5% over 30 years, a fixed-payment loan costs $313,212 in interest and an equal-principal loan costs $248,188. That $65,025 gap is real, and so is the reason it exists: the equal-principal borrower pays thousands more in each of the first ten years.
Two ways to repay the same loan
Every amortising loan answers one question: how much of this month's payment is principal, and how much is interest? There are two common answers, and the choice between them changes both the monthly figure and the total cost.
In a fixed-payment loan (an annuity, and the default almost everywhere in the US and UK), the total payment never changes. Interest is charged on the outstanding balance first; whatever remains of the payment reduces the principal. Because the balance is large at the start, interest takes the biggest share of the early payments and a shrinking share later. The payment feels predictable because it is, from month one to month 360.
In an equal-principal loan (also called straight-line or capital-repayment), the principal portion is identical every month: the amount borrowed divided by the number of payments. Interest on top is charged on the balance still owed, which falls by the same amount each month. The result is a payment that starts high and declines in a straight line, finishing at roughly half of where it began.
The arithmetic of each
The fixed payment comes from the annuity formula, where P is the principal, r the monthly rate (annual rate ÷ 12 ÷ 100) and n the number of payments:
M = P × r / (1 − (1 + r)−n)
For $300,000 at 5.5% over 30 years, r is 0.0045833 and n is 360, which gives $1,703.37. Note what the formula does not contain: any term for "principal per month". The principal portion is whatever is left after interest, so it grows as the balance shrinks.
The equal-principal payment is simpler to write down and slightly harder to live with:
paymentt = P / n + balancet−1 × r
Month one is 833.33 + 300,000 × 0.0045833 = 2,208.33. Month 360 is 833.33 + 833.33 × 0.0045833 = 837.15. The principal column is a flat line; the interest column declines; the sum declines with it.
The numbers, side by side
Same $300,000, same 5.5%, same 30 years:
| Measure | Fixed payment | Equal principal |
|---|---|---|
| Payment in month 1 | $1,703.37 | $2,208.33 |
| Payment in month 360 | $1,703.37 | $837.15 |
| Paid in the first year | $20,440.40 | $26,247.92 |
| Interest, total | $313,212.12 | $248,187.50 |
| Repaid, total | $613,212.12 | $548,187.50 |
The equal-principal borrower hands over $5,807.51 more in year one alone and $65,024.62 less over thirty years. Both facts come from the same schedule; they are not in tension, they are the trade.
Where the gap is widest
Interest is a charge on time and balance, so the months in which the balance is highest do the most damage. In the fixed-payment version of this loan, the first year's payments are $16,399 interest and $4,041 principal — 80% of the money is rent on the debt. The first month in which principal finally exceeds interest arrives at month 139, more than eleven years in. In the equal-principal version the split is different from day one: month one is $1,375 interest against $833 principal, and the crossover happens in month seven.
This is why the two structures diverge fastest in the early years and converge towards the end. If you sell or refinance after five years, you have barely begun to benefit from the equal-principal structure's lower total interest — but you also have a visibly smaller balance, which is the figure that matters at resale.
Why the smaller total is not automatically cheaper
The $65,025 difference is a nominal figure accumulated over thirty years, and comparing it to today's cash requires care. Three points decide the matter:
- Present value. Money saved in year 28 is worth far less than money saved today. Discount the interest difference at even 3% a year and a large part of the gap shrinks.
- Opportunity cost. The equal-principal borrower has to find $505 more in month one and $400-plus more for years afterwards. Invested instead at a comparable after-tax return, that difference earns something of its own — which is exactly what the lender is doing with it.
- Liquidity and risk. Money paid into a house is hard to get back out; an emergency fund is not. A household that empties its savings to take the cheaper schedule has bought a lower total cost and a higher chance of missing a payment.
None of this says the gap is imaginary. It says a 30-year nominal difference is not the same as a 30-year advantage, and the decision depends on what the extra cash would otherwise do.
Who each shape suits
Fixed payment suits borrowers whose income is steady but not rising fast: the payment is predictable, inflation erodes its real cost over time, and the affordability test at the start is the only one you have to pass. It also suits anyone likely to move within a decade, because the lower initial outlay leaves more room to save.
Equal principal suits borrowers with high current income and a preference for paying less interest overall, particularly those who expect income to fall later (approaching retirement, for instance) and want a payment that declines with it. It requires qualifying for the higher initial payment, which is the practical obstacle: lenders assess serviceability on month one, not month 200.
Five mistakes when comparing the two
- Comparing total interest only. Total interest is one line of the comparison, not the answer. Cash flow, liquidity and the alternative use of money belong beside it.
- Assuming equal principal is on offer everywhere. It is standard in parts of continental Europe and Asia and uncommon in the US and UK, where lenders mostly sell annuities. Ask rather than assume.
- Forgetting that the declining payment is nominal. A payment that falls 0.3% a month in cash terms falls faster in real terms if inflation is 3%, which makes the later years cheaper than the schedule suggests.
- Qualifying on the wrong number. If the lender stresses month one, the equal-principal loan may simply not be available at the size you want, however attractive the total looks.
- Ignoring fees. Some lenders price the two products differently: arrangement fees, valuation fees and rate discounts can swamp a five-figure interest difference over a short holding period.
Running your own comparison
The mortgage calculator models the fixed-payment schedule: payment, total interest and the balance at the end of each year. To price the equal-principal alternative by hand, divide the loan by the number of months (that is your principal line), then add 1/12 of the annual rate multiplied by the balance still outstanding. The two columns will look like the table above.
If your real question is "how do I pay less interest without changing product", the answer is usually overpayment, which is covered in what an extra payment really saves and can be simulated on the payoff calculator.
FAQ
Is an equal-principal mortgage always cheaper?
At the same rate and term it always costs less interest, because the balance falls faster. Whether it is cheaper for you depends on what the higher early payments would otherwise have done, and on whether you keep the loan long enough for the interest saving to outweigh the extra cash paid in the first years.
Can I get an equal-principal mortgage in the US or UK?
It exists but is not mainstream. Some credit unions and specialist lenders offer it, and a few lenders will structure a loan with a fixed principal component on request. In much of continental Europe and in parts of Asia it is a standard product, often the default.
Does overpaying a fixed-payment loan turn it into equal principal?
Only partly. Overpayments reduce the balance faster, which cuts future interest in the same way, but the contractual payment stays the same rather than declining. The effect on total interest is similar; the effect on monthly cash flow is not.
Try it: see your own payment, total interest and yearly balance table. open the mortgage calculator
Keep reading
- What an extra payment really saves
- Using a compound interest calculator honestly
- Mortgage payment and amortisation calculator
Written by the CalcNest team. Last updated November 19, 2026.